Site icon Harcourts One

More Homes, Fewer Buyers: What the October Numbers Mean for Sellers in San Diego County and Temecula Valley

Yes. In September 2026, Redfin counted 62.6 percent more home sellers than buyers nationwide, the widest gap in its records back to 2013. Realtor.com reported active listings up 7.4 percent in October while homes under contract fell 10.5 percent. If your home is sitting, the market shifted under it.

How big is the gap between sellers and buyers?

The gap is the widest Redfin has ever measured. In September 2026, Redfin estimated 928,892 buyers in the market, the lowest number in its records dating back to 2013 and the fifth straight monthly decline. On the other side it counted 1,510,784 sellers, the most since March 2020. That leaves 62.6 percent more sellers than buyers, up from 56.9 percent in August and the fourth straight month the gap set a record. By Redfin’s definition, a market where sellers outnumber buyers by more than 10 percent is a buyer’s market, and 41 of the 50 largest metro areas now qualify.

Realtor.com tells the same story from the inventory side. Active listings reached 1,183,520 in October 2026, up 7.4 percent from a year earlier, the fourth straight month of faster growth. At the same time, the stock of homes under contract fell 10.5 percent year over year, the steepest annual decline since October 2023. New listings actually fell 7.5 percent, the steepest drop of 2026, so the pileup is not a flood of new sellers. It is homes staying listed longer because fewer buyers are signing contracts.

Zillow’s October Market Report adds the third confirmation. Newly pending listings fell 16.8 percent year over year, the biggest annual drop since August 2023 and the slowest October for new contracts since 2018. Completed existing home sales fell 8.7 percent to 304,105 homes.

Why are buyers stepping back right now?

Mortgage rates are the main reason, and the October numbers show how fast buying power shrank. The 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.33 percent in October, according to Realtor.com, after peaking at 7.40 percent in mid-October. That is roughly 110 basis points above a year earlier. Zillow estimated the typical monthly principal and interest payment at 2,004 dollars in October, assuming a 20 percent down payment and excluding taxes and insurance, up 12.8 percent from a year earlier.

When the monthly payment jumps that much, buyers do not disappear. They pause, they lower their price range, and they get pickier about the homes they will tour. That is why the buyer count fell to a record low even though there are more homes to choose from than there have been in years. Sellers feel it as fewer showings, longer waits between offers, and more low offers than they expected.

What does more inventory mean for your home’s price?

More competition means buyers compare your home against every similar listing, not just the one down the street. Nationally, the median list price was 415,000 dollars in October, according to Realtor.com, down 2.2 percent from a year earlier and the 12th straight month of annual declines. About 20.5 percent of active listings had a price cut in October, the highest October share since 2022.

A price cut can help, but on its own it rarely fixes a home that is not selling. If the photos, condition, or presentation gave buyers a reason to pass the first time, a lower price just invites the same buyers to pass again at a lower number. Before cutting again, read what actually moves a home that is not selling after repeated cuts.

The homes that are selling in this market tend to share three things: a price set for today’s buyer pool rather than last spring’s comparable sales, a first impression that earns the showing, and exposure that reaches buyers beyond the usual listing sites. If one of those three is missing, that is where to start, not with another cut.

Why are homes sitting longer even when the price looks fair?

Because time on market sends its own message. Zillow reported homes took a median of 31 days to go pending in October, two days longer than a year earlier, and the pace keeps slowing. When buyers see a home that has sat for weeks, many assume something is wrong with it, even when the real problem is timing and competition. That assumption is exactly why a stale listing draws lower offers than a fresh one at the same price. Days on Market: What Buyers Really Think When Your Home Sits Too Long

Sellers are mostly staying put rather than pulling their homes. Realtor.com reported a delisting rate of 4.4 percent in October, close to the 4.6 percent of a year earlier. So the inventory is not about to shrink on its own. Waiting for the market to thin out means waiting while more homes compete with yours.

What should sellers in San Diego County and Temecula Valley do differently?

Start by treating this as a relaunch, not a waiting game. First, price to the buyers who are actually shopping now. That means looking at the homes that went pending in the last 30 days near yours, not the peak prices from a year ago. Second, fix the first impression before the next showing. Fresh photos, a clean entry, and repairs on the small things buyers notice first cost far less than another price cut. Third, reach the buyers who already passed. Many of them are still shopping, and a genuine change in price, presentation, or terms is a reason to bring them back.

If your listing has already stalled, the answer is rarely one change. It is a coordinated reset of price, presentation, and exposure, which is the re-energize process in full: re-engage the buyers who passed, re-position the home for today’s market, and re-market it so it reaches fresh eyes. Expired Listings in San Diego County: What Changes the Second Time When the agent who listed your home seems out of ideas, that reset is the conversation to have, and it is worth having before another month passes. When Your Agent Runs Out of Ideas: What to Do When Your Listing Stalls

What if your home has already been sitting for weeks?

Then the market has already told you something, and the kindest thing you can do is listen to it early. A home that sits for 60 or 90 days does not get easier to sell with time. It gets harder, because every extra week adds to the story buyers tell themselves about it. The sellers who turn it around are the ones who change something real: the price, the presentation, the exposure, or the strategy behind all three. The rest of this series looks at the other pieces of the same problem. Tomorrow: deals falling apart before closing, and what that means for sellers counting on a signed contract.

Questions sellers are asking

Are there really more sellers than buyers right now?

Yes. Redfin estimated 62.6 percent more sellers than buyers in September 2026, the widest gap in its records back to 2013, with buyers at their lowest level on record and sellers at their highest since March 2020.

Does that mean home prices are crashing?

No. The national median list price fell 2.2 percent year over year in October, according to Realtor.com, which is a cooler market, not a crash. Prices are softening while buyers gain negotiating room.

Should I take my home off the market until spring?

It depends on your timeline, but waiting has a cost. Sellers are not withdrawing in large numbers, so the competition will still be there, and a fresh listing later still faces the same buyer pool unless something about the home or the strategy changes first.

What is the first thing to change if my home is not selling?

Start with positioning, not another cut. Check the price against homes that went pending recently, fix the first impression, and make sure the listing reaches buyers beyond the usual sites. If the home has sat for weeks, a full relaunch beats another small adjustment.

If your home is sitting in this market, Jesse can help with pricing, marketing, and negotiation, including the re-energize process for homes that have not sold: re-engage the buyers who passed, re-position the home for today’s buyers, and re-market it to fresh eyes. Start with a free home valuation and a straightforward conversation about what would need to change for your home to sell. Harcourts One serves sellers across San Diego County and Southwest Riverside County (Temecula Valley).

Exit mobile version