Site icon Harcourts One

Pending Home Sales Are Sinking: What the Record-Low Numbers Mean for Sellers in San Diego County and Temecula Valley

Pending home sales are sinking in San Diego County and Temecula Valley. In September, pending sales fell 4% from August on Redfin’s measure and 7.3% on the National Association of Realtors index, the lowest reading in that index’s history. Fewer signed contracts now means fewer closings ahead, so sellers need a plan that wins the buyers who are buying.

What does “pending home sales down” actually mean?

A pending sale is a signed contract that has not closed yet. When pending sales fall, fewer buyers are signing contracts, and that shows up as fewer closings one to two months later. It is the closest thing the housing market has to a forward-looking number.

How far did pending sales fall in September?

They fell sharply on both national measures. Redfin reported that pending sales declined 4% from August in September on a seasonally adjusted basis, the biggest monthly drop in more than three years, to the lowest level since spring 2014, with the exception of April 2020. For the first time in three years, pending sales fell in every one of the 50 most populous metros.

The National Association of Realtors reported a steeper drop on its own index: down 7.3% in September from August and 11.3% from a year earlier, landing at 66.0, the lowest reading since the index began in 2001. Every region fell, and the West fell the most, down 9.2% in a month and 15.0% from a year earlier.

The weakness carried into November. Redfin’s weekly update for the four weeks ending November 8 showed pending sales at 275,980, down 15.5% from a year earlier and still the lowest level in Redfin’s records, which go back to 2021.

Closed sales are already feeling it. The National Association of Realtors reported that existing-home sales fell 5.5% in October to a 3.75 million annual pace, the slowest since August 2010.

Why did pending sales sink when mortgage rates dipped?

Rates are part of the story, but they are not the whole story. Mortgage rates climbed above 7% at the end of September, reaching 7.28% on Redfin’s weekly measure, the highest level in three years. The National Association of Realtors chief economist pointed to fast-rising rates as the reason market conditions weakened. Then rates eased: Freddie Mac’s 30-year fixed averaged 7.11% for the week of November 12, the fourth straight weekly decline, and the median monthly mortgage payment fell to $2,755 in the four weeks ending November 8, a six-week low.

Yet pending sales barely moved. Redfin noted that dipping rates likely held off a bigger decline, but a slightly cheaper payment is not enough on its own to bring hesitant buyers back.

It also explains why price cuts alone are not moving homes. When the problem is a thin buyer pool rather than one overpriced house, cutting the price does not create new buyers. It only changes which seller the few active buyers pick.

What does this mean for sellers in San Diego County?

San Diego is near the front of the national decline, not behind it. Redfin reported that pending sales in San Diego fell 15.8% from a year earlier in September, the third steepest drop among the 50 largest metros. In the four weeks ending November 8, San Diego pending sales were down 26.9% from a year earlier, again among the steepest declines in the country.

For a San Diego seller, that means the competition is no longer just the house down the street. It is every other seller in the county chasing the same smaller group of buyers, and the homes that win are the ones buyers can picture themselves in from the first photo.

This is also why days on market matter more than they used to. Buyers notice a stale listing and wonder what is wrong with it. If your home has been sitting, a fresh approach matters more than another small price cut.

What does this mean for sellers in Temecula Valley?

Temecula Valley sellers face the same thin buyer pool, with one difference. Buyers who shop Temecula, Murrieta, and Menifee often compare across the whole valley and into San Diego County, so a home here competes in both markets at once.

When pending sales fall everywhere, a Temecula Valley listing cannot count on overflow demand from San Diego buyers the way it could when the market was hot. Active buyers compare value carefully, and they will pass over a home that looks tired, overpriced, or poorly presented.

Homes are still selling. The question for a Temecula Valley seller is not whether anyone is buying. It is whether your home is the one the remaining buyers choose.

What should you do if your home is not getting offers?

Start with the buyer, not the price. A home that is not getting offers in a thin market usually has a positioning problem, a presentation problem, or a pricing problem.

First, look at your home the way a buyer sees it online. Most buyers decide whether to visit from the photos, so the first image has to earn the click. If the photos look dark, dated, or cluttered, fix that before you touch the price.

Second, check your pricing against the homes buyers are actually choosing, not the homes that sold months ago. In a falling market, last spring’s comparable sales can mislead you.

Third, widen the net. A listing that only appears on the MLS is easy for buyers to miss when fewer of them are searching. Paid digital exposure beyond the MLS matters more when the buyer pool is thin, which is why Harcourts One invests in extra exposure for its listings, including Zillow Showcase, Realtor.com Spotlight, and Homes.com Maximum Exposure where included for a property.

Fourth, if your listing has already expired or stalled, treat the relaunch as a new launch. A new price alone is not a new strategy. The re-energize process, Re-Engage, Re-Position, Re-Market, re-engages the buyers and agents who passed the first time, re-positions the home with fresh photos, presentation, and pricing, and re-markets it to buyers who never saw it.

Finally, be honest about timing. If you need to move, waiting for the market to turn depends on something you cannot control. A better plan is to make your home the most compelling choice for the buyers who are buying now.

Questions sellers are asking about falling pending sales

What is a pending home sale?
A pending home sale is a signed purchase contract that has not closed yet. It usually closes within one to two months, which is why pending sales are watched as a leading indicator.

Why are pending home sales down?
Pending sales fell because fewer buyers signed contracts in September. Redfin tied the drop to mortgage rates climbing above 7%, and even as rates eased in November, buyers stayed cautious.

Does falling pending sales mean home prices will fall?
Not necessarily. Prices held up nationally even as pending sales sank, with Redfin reporting prices up just 1.3% from a year earlier in September. The direct effect sellers feel first is fewer buyers and longer selling times.

Should I still list my home if pending sales are down?
It depends on your situation, but a thin market is not a no-sale market. Homes are still selling every week, and the sellers who succeed now price for today’s buyers, present the home at its best, and market it widely enough to reach the buyers who are still active.

My home has been sitting for weeks. Is it too late to fix it?
No. A stale listing can be relaunched with fresh photos, a corrected price, and a new marketing push. The key is to change the presentation and the positioning, not just the price, so buyers see a new opportunity rather than the same listing at a lower number.

If your home is sitting while pending sales sink, you do not need to wait for the market to rescue you. Jesse can help you re-energize your listing with the Re-Engage, Re-Position, Re-Market process, price it for the buyers who are buying now, and market it widely enough to reach them. Get a free home valuation at https://www.salassells.com/home-valuation/ and talk through your next move.

Jesse Salas and Harcourts One serve sellers across San Diego County and Southwest Riverside County, including Temecula Valley.

Exit mobile version